Advertisement
can you use menstrual blood as fertilizer? how is it applied (directly or diluted?) and how often should it be given to plants? i've read that plants love it, but is there any sort of evidence backing this up? has anyone grown plants that were given menstrual blood vs. no fertilizer side by side to see which one does better? how potent of a fertilizer is it? what exact nutrients does it give to a plant? there seems to be no information on this sort anywhere online.
posted by:
|
|
Unsubscribed |
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Thu, August 26, 2004 - 12:18 PMi know that menstrual blood attracts ants like nothing i've even seen so you might wanna keep that in mind if spreading it on stuff inside or near your people places.
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Thu, August 26, 2004 - 1:32 PMa woman i know wears those cotton moon pads...then when it is full, she lets it soak in a bucket of water and then pours the menstrual-water on the plants
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Thu, August 26, 2004 - 4:00 PMI don't know the nutritive difference between human menstrual and slaughterhouse (cow, pig, chicken, etc) blood but blood meal is used by some as a high nitrogen fertilizer.
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, August 27, 2004 - 10:07 AMI would guess that menstrual blood would have the same / very similar properties as blood meal.
The main benefit I have found in my research is nitrogen, and potential boosting of compost piles. (see www.ext.vt.edu/department...n89pr6.html by the Virginia Tech Coop Extension for more detail)
A BIG CONCERN I would have in using any blood-based products is the possibility of contamination of plants (particularly any that you would expect to use as food and/or decoration) with any potential blood-borne agents.
As noted on www.organicconsumers.org/madco...04.cfm there are (and likely will continue to be) concerns with BSE and other blood/tissue contaminants.
Do keep in mind that blood contaminants are not simply diseases like BSE, etc. -- there are other components of one's blood that can make you or others ill if handled improperly and/or ingested -- largely due to what may grow/culture in the blood. Not to mention any unwelcome pests that may be drawn to "raw" blood in your garden.
Note: blood meal is dried largely for better/easier packaging and transport but also because a lot of risks are eliminated with the water. Most "bad things" need moisture to grow.
So, I would suggest closely considering what you would be fertilizing with your menses, as I'm guessing you're not going to be drying them out in your oven before applying them to your plants. Perhaps a separate compost pile that you use for non-food / not-in-the-house plants would be a good choice, as I'm guessing that composting the blood (much as you would with manure) may decrease or eliminate the blood-specific risks.
For example, I recall reading in Sage Woman [ www.sagewoman.com ] some time ago about a woman's ritual garden: she composted her menses and used them to fertilize the herbs etc she later used in ritual. I thought that was a =very= powerful application!
To sum up: if you're going to apply a blood product to any plants you expect to eat/handle often, dry out or compost the blood first to reduce/eliminate the health risks.
Please keep us posted on what you choose to do! -LA -
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, August 27, 2004 - 11:00 AMwell i was thinking of diluting the blood first before applying them to plants. i don't know if that would decrease the risk or not. i live with 4 guys, so i'm not sure if they'd be too happy about me baking my blood in the oven! :P
thanks for all the info, this is all very helpful! -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, August 27, 2004 - 11:36 AMDilution won't do anything to mitigate the health risks: drying or composting are the only means I've seen that would have any impact. Dilution would simply spread any problem(s) over a larger area!
-LA -
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, August 27, 2004 - 12:37 PMwould it be unhygenic to bake the blood in the oven to dry it out? or does the heat kill all the bacteria?
-
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, August 27, 2004 - 11:11 PMi would not be happy if my neighbors were putting out body fluids near my home, baked or otherwise. there are rules for disposal of things like human sewage and blood and such. i have a well, right outside my house, from which i drink and bathe.. and i would hope that this kind of practice is VERY VERY VERY far away from me.
as a woman, i find it very... objectionable. i am sensitive and know what people are trying to do, but.. it's just... asking too much, in my opinion. i understand this is my opinion.. and women are free to just.. broadcast their menstrual blood on their yards...
lordy...
we don't allow human or cat or dog feces in our compost. this is the same family of ickiness to me. -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sat, August 28, 2004 - 2:22 PM
Well, I hope that you grow all of your own food, because the amount of human biosludge being applied to food production would probably turn you into an instant anorexic if you knew...and those wastes are from anyone and everyone. And I cannot vouch for the effectiveness of the treatments being applied, either.
Heat-dried blood will not have any kind of pathogen left in it, and would be no different from the bonemeal and bloodmeal you buy at the garden shop, except that it would be much closer to you personally and possibly much cleaner.
I am also very alert and skeptical about what kinds of potentially dangerous materials I apply to my gardens, but when they are clean and pathogen-free, I wouldn't let squeamishness (no offense intended) rob me of a good thing and make me treat a powerful physical/spiritual resource like it is something nasty. I would get more upset if my neighbor was spraying chemicals or using various lawn products which will leach into my well.
Life happens. Enjoy.
:-) -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, August 29, 2004 - 1:40 PMMost food is grown with no organic fertilizer at all, only chemical NPK fertilizer.
I think that a feeling of ickiness and contamination from menstrual blood, rather than power, touches on other issues besides gardening.
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Tue, August 31, 2004 - 8:27 PMindeed, an aversion to a stranger's menstrual blood relates to many issues besides gardening.. like health. :) bloody solutions in buckets sitting around waiting to be baked are a health risk. I don't care what precautions people think they are taking at certain points! Body fluids accumulating in my neighbors' garage is not something i would want around my children or pets. Forget the ground water contamination issue, though it is a real one. We have our well tested often, and often find contamination from dangerous organisms from aerobic septic systems that aren't maintained. There are many infections diseases borne by human body fluids. My aversion is to other people's body fluids because of possible health risks, not to women or men or sexuality, for the record, as i feel has been insinuated. :)
I don't use blood on my plants at all in any form, not from animals or humans, and i don't put human feces on my plants, nor is it recommended. human sewage must be treated because of health risks to other humans; that's not something i felt or thought or made up. health risks aren't always obvious or known, for example; scientists never dreamed that mad cow disease would manifest as it has or be transferred to humans as it has. (i really didn't think i would have to explain my feelings about this...)
I find composted manure from herbivores to be very acceptable, given that the animals are healthy. i do not put meat in my compost or dog or cat feces or any other body fluid from humans or body parts from animals.
I wouldn't put sperm on my plants either, and i hope my neighbor isn't masturbating into buckets to dilute and pour on his plants for "life force."
i was expecting to be crucified for not being PC about a woman's issue (har har), but so far the responses have been very moderate. i didn't post for days because i was afraid to say what i thought; i repressed my feelings for fear of what women would say to me! now that's interesting...but a topic for another tribe eh.
i'm glad this topic is being discussed, and i'm glad i am free to give my opinion on it. :) i had no idea people could or would be doing this!
-
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Tue, August 31, 2004 - 10:47 PMAs a healthcare worker I have a healthy (no pun intended) respect for body fluids, blood and otherwise. Blood borne pathogens have a finite life outside of the body. HIV for instance lives for a very short time and is not high in menstrual blood. Hepatitis a much more prevalent and bigger concern in hospitals and lives up to 30 hours on surfaces but breaks down with heat, sunlight, not to mention what several meters of soil could filter out. So for those few people who chose to sneeze all over Muni, spit on the ground, shit in our water, let dogs and cats, birds and all other living creatures excrete when and where they please AND broadcast diluted menstrual blood into their gardens, GO FOR IT! In my humble opinion, risks are low for transmission of blood borne disease. And what doesn't kill ya makes you stronger, right? -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, May 9, 2008 - 4:45 AMI guess that the Dr. I saw interviewed on the tele. must have been wrong ! He was a surgeon who operated on AIDS patients and when asked about the life of AIDS outside the body replied " In a wet state 3 to 4 days and in a dry state 2 to 3 hours " . What are you taught now ?
-
-
-
-
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, August 29, 2004 - 10:59 AMfrecklyfawn, how do you feel about people using manure as fertilizer in their yard? that's cow feces... -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, August 30, 2004 - 11:06 AMI have used it on my house plants for years, just diluted in water once a month! They are all happy, healthy plants.....
I have a friend who watered her zucchini plant with it one summer, and won the largest zucchini contest at the fair...... -
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Tue, August 31, 2004 - 3:55 PMI have been using diluted moon time blood and pouring it onto my white sage and other plants I use for either my own rituals or my own medicines. I have only been doing this for about four months but everyone seems pretty happy (even my plants!)
One wonders what was done with the straw used to bleed into while in the Red Tent (another tribe...) or other indiginous moon lodge locations...
Happy Earth connection everyone! -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Wed, September 8, 2004 - 8:10 AMreply to you spiral mama, in some cultures out west the bricks of the adobe were made with mud ,water and menstral blood, and these lodges were for women only, and my girl friend used her blood and it was free and organic fertilizer, it was proceesed by a plant and made food for the yeilder, and give and take relationship, i still have the seeds from the line of plants i have growing for years using the same process, they are hardy healthy and tasty, also there is apersonal connection to the whole process, its non invasive completely organic,no karma...other words , no trips to lowes, wallmart or any other fertilizer distributers, no blood from slaughter houses or supporting corporate dissention in one more aspect of our lives so we seem like flakes when we profess our lifestyles that can be debunked and dissolusioned by anyone with knowledge of how the industry touches us all with its evil subjectations, phew....what i am tring to say gardening is a personal thing and it's best to keep the trail to your food narrow and from point a to point b kitchen to garden and back. -
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Wed, September 8, 2004 - 10:25 AMwell i just got my period today so i will be trying this out, i will let you guys know what happens. -
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Wed, September 8, 2004 - 11:17 AMim w/freckly fawn on this one.
ive never in my life heard of menstrual blood as fertilizer.
in alaska my neighbors composted their solid human waste and used it to fertilize the flower garden downslope from the vegie garden. their system was a cool process that took years to get going properly, although i don't know too much about it. i do know that they didn't fertilize anything they were going to eat w/it.
i dont think that's you're intention - to fertilize your food w/it, sounds like you're going to do houseplants and stuff.
that's interesting about the navajo/apache natives using their menstrual blood in construction. i find it hard to believe. i personally know nothing about that culture. in souix/chippewa/tlingit/haida tribes a woman's moon cycle was quite the event, that involved a lot of gender-segregation, solitude and spirituality. i've never heard of any ritual in which the menstrual blood was actually handled or used for any utilitarian purpose.
im in civil engineering and in most places in the lower 48 outhouses are illegal per zoning. for good reason. human fluids/wastes have to be contained and treated. and in regards to menstrual blood, whatever the absense of air born pathogens or the finite life of blood born diseas, in my mind- it should just be discarded hygenically.
peace and love !!!
-
-
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, March 11, 2007 - 2:05 PMI too have used it on my houseplants (& trees) for decades now..no problem, happy plants.
-
-
-
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, September 12, 2004 - 9:35 PMI've been doing it for a long time. I don't know what nutrients it provides but it seems to me too good of a thing to waste. I appreciate the spiritual aspect of gifting my blood back to the earth. I feel that's where it belongs. I've been watering a passionflower with the soak water from my cotton pads and it's doing beautifully. Came back from near dead. For those who think it's horrible. Is it horrible when you have to soak dirty clothes to get out stains? I doubt anyone is letting a bucket of blood (who bleeds that much anyway?!!) sit around. If you use cloth pads then you pretty much have to soak them to get them clean. If you don't use cloth then what do you use? Keep that dioxin bleached rayon fiber stuff away from tender special places! That is more likely a greater health hazard than feeding plants your body fluids! (I love the image of some man masturbating onto his soil to improve fertility - makes me laugh just thinking of it!)
Have to admit I really enjoyed shitting in a bucket at an alternative building conference recently to add to their humanure system (there's a great book on the subject that documents health hazards and environmental benefits of that - The Humanure Handbook). Also have a friend who uses the bucket system for he and his wife - they are very particular about who uses it - if you've been traveling you have to use the commode!
I've been to many a non-industrial country and seem the results of poor sanitation. There's a big difference between shitting in your food and water sources and using human waste (menstrual blood and other) as nutrient sources. When properly handled I've not seen anything bad come of it yet. The key is giving it enough time to compost before you do anything with it. -
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, September 13, 2004 - 10:38 AMSo I talked to my friend in Homer this weekend and she does this to her houseplants. She also read somewhere (can't remember-we were getting shitfaced) about a woman who witnessed the Xunu (sp?) tribe in California running through their cornfields under a full moon.
I told her this was the grossest thing I ever heard of and she thinks that's funny. So-Mama Botanica... I see now that people actually do this. Carry on. But I'll give you the same advice I gave her: try not to get it mixed up w/your batches of red wine.
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, September 13, 2004 - 1:25 PMI think it's interesting that there were many more stong opnions voiced on this subject than urinating in/on your compost. Funny how this is so much more tabu for some people.
just a random observation.
JG -
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, September 13, 2004 - 1:48 PMSomebody was urinating on their compost???
I think the term "Organic" should be defined. I just joined this tribe so maybe its not my place... but it sounds to me like this is being used a little loosely. (And I would probably be considered a loose woman)
-
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, September 13, 2004 - 2:03 PMurine is a really good fertilizer. rich in nitrogen, i think. i just bought this book called liquid gold, about using urine as fertilizer, but haven't had a chance to really read it yet.
www.liquidgoldbook.com/ -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, September 13, 2004 - 3:43 PMAs has been discussed on several threads here, urine is excellent fertilizer, rich in both nitrogen and potassium, and, due to the nitrogen content, speeds up the decomposition of compost.
What is not "organic" about it?
Urine comes out of the body sterile, unless there is a bladder/urinary track infection. The conversion of urine to yucky-smelling ammonia can be prevented by neutralizing it with lime (dolomite powder).
(Do not apply it to plants directly unless you neutralize it first and dilute it with water like 10/1.)
As for menstrual blood, it is no less hygienic than other blood, straight out of the body. Any blood can be a medium for bacterial growth once out of the body, but much less so when spread around than concentrated, and it decomposes rapidly. Any blood can carry blood-borne infections, but to my knowledge none of these infections survive decomposition. The negative reactions to =menstrual blood in particular= (as opposed to blood in general) have more to do with negative attitudes toward Moontime itself than to any practical hygienic consideration. -
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, September 13, 2004 - 4:04 PMYup! We used to put lime in the outhouse in Homer (as well as sawdust).
I didn't read through all the threads before I posted in this one, I'm on it.
Urine is TOTALLY organic. But SHOULD it be used as fertilizer? Rich in nitrogen or not. That's what I meant by "define organic". Same thing w/menstrual blood. Rich in nutrients, all natural, organic. As I said earlier, "whatever the absence of air born pathogens or the finite life of blood born disease", I was just wondering if it SHOULD be used for fertilier. After learning several people I know actually do this, I recanted. Party on fellow organic growers!!
Lastly, Gayle - I've percieved there is a correlation between finding it gross to handle my menstrual blood, and my general attitude towards my moon cycle (or womanhood, or what have you) - in your post and in several others. I totally embrace my feminity, womanhood, moon cycle, female power, and sisters. But I still think it's gross. Perhaps instead of discussing the hygienic nature of this practice, we should focus on the philosophy of it?? It seems to me like these are two seperate issues: do you agree? (Peace and Love!!!) -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Wed, September 29, 2004 - 7:47 AMi use my midflow morning piss for my compost as an activator...maybe using it in winter more than summer...do this about once a month and its fantastic! but then i use urine for other theropy as well! its great.
as to blood, and in particular menstrual blood, fantastic... really cool to hear you all talk about it! blood is great to use and id use it in my compost! as for dilutions or other uses on plant for ritual i think thats brilliant. ive used blood in ritual many times and for plants it can be great. also heaps of mates do this and no problems so far! we all get a wee(no pun intended) bit over concerned about bodily fluids or not so fluid stuff sometimes.
agree health risks are not so high, unless there twenty people in the house putting it all on the one begonia in the window box!
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Wed, September 29, 2004 - 10:36 PMi can't believe this thread is still haunting the tribe.
we use poop, but not cat or dog poop, even if our pets are healthy. its organic.. but we don't use it. "you are what you eat" is somewhat true, but if you feed cows cows, you get mad cows. logic is tricky sometimes. can you see the principle? at all? sometimes a thing seems "right," but it ain't right.... it just ain't right.
what is so hard to understand about this? I think people go too far the other way... this is my opinion. it's the same principle as reverse discrimination. it's like.. overcompensating for something --which doesn't help and isn't dealing with reality but imposing something unnatural and bordering on the perverse. animals get rid of afterbirth and blood ASAP, for example. if they dont, they die. i don't think they are ashamed of their femininity or their offspring. i think it's instinctual and linked to survival. if you save bloody rags and make solutions of bloody water to put on your plants in grizzly country you just might die a horrible death. pioneer women and Native Americans knew this very well. i think it's over the top to go to so much trouble to put human blood and human body fluids on plants, and it's probably a side effect of misogynistic practices in society---it sure seems reactionary. i find no reason to do it that satifies me. i believe it is not a healthy... ahem...practice for humans. i ain't even considering the plants here.
no health organizations handle blood or body fluids, healthy or not, and they even hire companies to deal with bodily waste to avoid spreading disease. there are laws to protect the environment and people from such things! even the dang dentist wears gloves, and i don't take it personally. it has nothing to do with my being a woman. it's just a way of the dentist avoiding a health risk. the swabs from healthy women's pap smears go in the medical waste bin after testing. they are disposed of according to safe practices by women who love women.
what's good for doctors and health care workers is good for all of us. :) i dont see them saving bloody rags to make fertilizer. and i sure as heck don't think they would recommend it to their neighbors. if they did, i would never visit them.. or their neightbors.
peace and love with rubber gloves...
please.. be responsible.
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, October 4, 2004 - 4:50 AMi understand what your saying but i cant agree with you.
what i will agree on is responsibility but were not talking about throwing blood all over the place. i feel like you're implying that. i agree you should treat blood with care. however its important not to turn it into some personal monster. lets not forget our fear of bacteria has led to over use of anti-biotics, the development of super bugs and bodies that cant even cope with a basic infection that years ago wouldn't have been an issue.
i think its important to be in touch with yourself and that's about recognition and respect but not irrational fear.
modernity creates more problems than it solves. "mad cows" as you put it isn't about cows eating themselves its about a skrewed up meat/farm industry that commodifies life. i lived through that disaster in the UK and its seriously misunderstood problem.
animals, as you put it "get rid of their afterbirth", funny i thought they ate it... but did anyone say anything about using afterbirth on plants anyway?
women and for that matter men have used bodily fluids in ritual and practice for Milena. the reasons are many and varied.
and sorry, I'm really not trying to dig at you but "what's good for doctors and health care workers is good for all of us." is in my opinion very far from the truth. they are divided on this issue as on most things. i know no doctors who Ive spoken to decry the idea of using blood, again its about using it appropriately and respectfully. id also add that doctors and so on are not gods, though many think they are and are fallible. anyone who has been seriously ill can tell you that.
finally id say its really just about using common sense.
lol
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, October 15, 2004 - 9:37 AMDon't use your human waste (blood, urine, excrement) in your compost.
Hormones in Human Waste may be leading factor in reproductive eggs found in the sex organs of male bass:
www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6253193/ -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, October 17, 2004 - 5:41 AMhormones get into the water system through various means... not least our own sewage/waste desposal systems. though i take your point.
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sat, March 10, 2007 - 1:43 PM -
-
Re: How about using it as an ingredient in manure tea
Sat, March 10, 2007 - 5:22 PMIt would be transformed by the process.
How sis it go? did you do a test ?
I have heard it is like magic for plants. -
-
Unsu...
Re: How about using it as an ingredient in manure tea
Mon, March 12, 2007 - 6:48 AMI think that these rituals could have been used a lot more in historic times when their eating and lifestyles were purer.
"You are what you eat" had been mentioned here a lot, but perhaps not as simply as: if you eat non-organic food (to your knowledge anyway), take any medications, or drugs, or anything that contains anything unnatural (hard not to at least one of these), I'd leave it out of the earth.
Thinking of the earth first.
I've heard of the menses on plants thing, too. Sounds wonderfully womanly spiritualistic, and I've wanted to try it. I, aslso think in houseplants it's okay. Do whatever you want to plants that aren't in the earth in my opinion.
Hadn't heard of urine.... I suppose it's the same. It is hard to rid oneself of any preconceived notions - so obviously if we aren't completely comfortable with it we do it.
I hope you let us know how it goes for you! I've been wanting to use my menses for my houseplants - if you use tampons how do you save the blood? I guess I could just be inactive the first day and save it another way...
Peace,
Lynn -
-
moon fertilizer
Thu, March 29, 2007 - 11:43 PMgreat thread.
the whole 'thinking of the earth first' part is a bit of a quagmire though, no? because where do you think your 'waste' goes when you flush it down the toilet?
lots of ways to think of the earth i guess: a garbage heap, your home, wasteland, your mother, etc.
seems to me a more holistic way of thinking of the earth might be to think of myself as part of it and it as part of me and try to find as many practices and technologies to reinforce that holistic intrinsic relationship. reinstate the inevitable cycle with a healthy respect for all of the parts and functions of the whole, including all the nectars secreted... (yes piss and blood too)
the beauty is we have the technology and intelligence to remember old or create new processes that nourish and renourish earth and us, the ugly is that we are so fearful even of ourselves!
the Humanure Handbook by JC Jenkins covers mostly composting human feces and how to transform pathogens and build incredibly rich fertilizer to nourish the earth (as opposed to flushing 'waste' 'away' and fertilizing with intense chemical treatments), and it seems to me if you worry that blood will carry evils, that composting it would be an excellent way to reap the rubies and transform the... uh,. whatever it is you're afraid of.
also, i think composting your blood and poop is just another fine reason to consider what you put in and on your body. -
-
Unsu...
Re: moon fertilizer
Fri, March 30, 2007 - 12:26 AMIm planning to use Goat entrails to water my roses
-
-
-
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, March 12, 2007 - 11:58 AMI would be concerned about E Coli,
"Infection with E. coli often leads to bloody diarrhea, and occasionally to kidney failure. People can become infected with E.coli O157:H7 in a variety of ways. Though most illness has been associated with eating undercooked, contaminated ground beef, people have also become ill from eating contaminated bean sprouts or fresh leafy vegetables such as lettuce and spinach. Person-to-person contact in families and child care centers is also a known mode of transmission. In addition, infection can occur after drinking raw milk and after swimming in or drinking sewage-contaminated water." -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, March 12, 2007 - 1:13 PMWhat an interesting discussion. We live in a society that can't handle bodily excretions and its so hard to get away from that aversion. I know that urine is sterile, and can be used to neutralize the venom of jellyfish. In the Phillippines, my buddy had his friends take a whizz on his foot after being stung by a Man O' War. They say it saved his life.
I'm not sure if I'm ready to recycle my menstrual blood. But I do find the concept intriguing. Please let us know how it works.
Oh, and on the subject of e coli and other bacteria. We fertilize early to mid season, not just before harvest. I think all of the e coli outbreaks associated with leafy veggies came from irrigation water contaminated by the cattle ranch next door.
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Tue, March 13, 2007 - 12:26 AMe coli comes from our bowels cows bowels etc, menstrual blood is from the kidney/liver system there should be no e coli to worry about
blood meal (slaughterhouse waste) is used widely in organic agriculture, it is a big nitrogen source, also iron and other nutrients
so yes it is nutrifying
I am curious though menstrual blood is a cleansing mechanism of the body right, maybe there are 'dirty' astral energies that are also carried away from the body with the blood, that would be best fed to something like flowers (which are good for cleaning these types of energy patterns)...instead of feeding it to the food plants -
-
Unsu...
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Tue, March 13, 2007 - 5:36 AMI must admit that this is one of the more entertaining threads I have seen in a long time
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Tue, March 13, 2007 - 5:51 AMWhat could be worse than slaughterhouse blood from
a spiritual perspective. Thanks for the info on bloodmeal
which I haven't used. Menstrual blood is the physical matter
that makes it possible for the most creative thing a human
can do. It represents creative potential.
Imagine the fear bound up in bloodmeal. -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Tue, March 13, 2007 - 3:00 PMGreat thread! I know a woman who has been fertlizing with her blood for years on houseplants.
I am a user of the keeper which at least reduces the amount of waste I put into the system due to my period, but I haven't tried fertilizing yet. Definitely fascinating!
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, March 25, 2007 - 12:22 PMexactly
slaughterhouse blood is just bad...what I was trying to illustrate is that it is an accepted practice, to use blood as a fertilizer, not that it is necessarily a good thing to use slaughterhouse blood
now about menstrual blood correct me if I am wrong but is it not part of a cleansing process?
I have heard that women who do lots of fasting and cleansing have a tendency to have a reduced menstrual flow and in some cases no flow...what does that say?
would you consider using it to fertilize your own food?
personally I would not, just a personal preference
feeding flowers and trees definitely -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, February 21, 2011 - 1:33 AM>>now about menstrual blood correct me if I am wrong but is it not part of a cleansing process? I have heard that women who do lots of fasting and cleansing have a tendency to have a reduced menstrual flow and in some cases no flow...what does that say?
I know this post is as old as sin but since no one ever answered.... In my own experiences with fasting and reduced periods, I came to the conclusion that calorie deprivation slows down, lightens, and lengthens menstrual cycles. It's not uncommon for anorexics and female athletes to get amenorrhoea, where their period stops altogether. I think the body becomes less prepared to bear children when calorie consumption is low and conserves energy for the "mother" instead.
-
-
-
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, March 18, 2007 - 11:19 AMI've been using menses water on my houseplants and in my compost pile for some time now.
Currently, I'm growing tomato seedlings and want to use this as part of their fertilizer. I would imagine seedlings are much more sensitive to concentration than houseplants are, though, and I'm not sure how much to use.
Looks like no one else is, either, just that the concentrations that come out of soaking a single pad in a bucketful of water seem to be OK for established plants.
Hm. Well, the liquid seaweed I'm using recommends diluting at 1 Tbs per 1 gallon water. So maybe I'll use that as a guideline and estimate about 1/2 Tbs per gallon (I use a menstrual cup and so have a little bit of undiluted stuff). -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Tue, March 20, 2007 - 10:05 AMI use the keeper too...save all of that precious menstral blood to be diluted with water and fed to my plants. They love it.
How sad that we have been fooled into believing that this pure life giving source is to be discarded. Menstral blood is rich in nutrition, and contains much more life giving substance than the blood you give at your local red cross.
12 March 2006
At the American College of Cardiology annual meeting, Abstracts 921-105 and 921-107 by researchers at the Keio University School of Medicine in Japan examined the use of endometrial cells to mimic heart muscle. The two studies derived endometrial cells from either umbilical cord blood or from menstrual blood. In both cases, some of the endometrial cells were able to contract simultaneously (roughly half the cells from menstrual blood and nearly all the cells from cord blood). Both sets of cells also exhibited cardiac gene expression and response to the chemicals which trigger cardiac contractions. The cord blood study went further, demonstrating that half the stem cells transformed into cardiomyocytes (primitive cardiac cells) in vitro.
www.acc.org/2006ann_meet...pySun12PM.pdf
-
-
the blood mysteries ~ women's blood is sacred
Sun, March 25, 2007 - 5:17 PMHello Jandari,
I recommend reading Susun Weed's book Healing Wise. She writes of the old ways and the blood mysteries. All of this talk about blood and it being unhygenic is ingrained in many of our psyches because of thousands of years of oppression of women.
In the old days, mentrual blood was used to fertilize the crops, and used in sacred ritual.
I am now post menopausal.
When I did bleed, I would soak my pads in a glass gallon jar and then water my plants with this water.
They were all very happy.
Moontime blessing, Julie -
-
Re: the blood mysteries ~ women's blood is sacred
Sun, March 25, 2007 - 9:22 PMtoday I read that the ancient Greeks used to mix menstrual blood with their seeds before planting
I also read that it needs to be used fresh, because if it sits around for more than a day it stinks bad
and
that women on birth control pills secrete the hormones from the pills into their menstrual blood
also I read that Maoris don't let menstruating women harvest or store the kumera (sweet potatoes) as they will rot
and in India when they let menstruating women harvest the ginger it all rotted
something about strong etheric forces
-
-
Re: the blood mysteries ~ women's blood is sacred
Mon, March 26, 2007 - 7:19 AMWell, it does get quite a smell to it after a few day. That is why is put my pads in a gallon jar with a lid.
Before people thought that women did harm to things because of their great power, women were
honored for this focused power they called in during menstration.
thanks for this topic....it feels good to me to speak about the old ways and women's lore.
peace, Julie
-
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, March 30, 2007 - 8:07 AM"can you use menstrual blood as fertilizer? how is it applied (directly or diluted?) and how often should it be given to plants? i've read that plants love it, but is there any sort of evidence backing this up? ' -Jandari
I suggest you do an experiment to find out what the limits are for menstral nurishment of plants ....
Take a fully loaded pad, and then sprinkle grass seds on it. Keep it damp and see if it starts growing grass "hair" ... you know, like the Chia pet ... z.about.com/d/inventors/...9/ramchia.jpg
If that works, then you could test a new idea of embedding grasss seeds in a fresh, new pad, and then wearing it. If you eventually feel new grass sprouts tickling you, then you know it is a success! ... and you can patent that invention as the Chia Pad. Certain to be a big seller!
Be sure to take pics to document your experiment. and feel free to post them here.
hehe -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sat, March 31, 2007 - 12:18 AMDid everyone notice that there was a 2-1/2 year gap in the thread? And the people who have posted recently are a totally different crowd.
Kinda like a living book, eh?
It seems there's a tension here between two basic issues: 1) hygiene, and 2) the appeal of completing/fulfilling an energetic cycle. Some people are clearly drawn to the idea of "plugging into" the waste/compost/regeneration cycle by using urine and menstrual blood as fertilizers. Others find this distasteful, just downright icky :-)
I can imagine a time when our toilets will link up conveniently with the compost pile (perhaps a kind of rolling, underground septic system). The chemicals contained in human waste products are not insignificant. My guess is that there's not really enough nutrients there to completely fertilize a full-scale vegetable garden, but it's not a trivial amount of chemicals. Perhaps the combination of fruit and vegetable scraps, human wastes, and yard wastes together would be enough to make a self-sufficient garden?
As someone who has spent a couple hundred bucks on soil and organic fertilizers over the past year, this is an eminently practical question for me.
It is worth considering that industrial-scale sewage treatment causes some environmental problems, pollution, etc. I recall reading specifically that the practice of combining urine and feces in the waste treatment process causes chemical reactions which are unhelpful. Sorry I have no source to cite for this.
Of course, no one wants something smelly or unhygienic in their house or backyard! But there are good practical, environmental reasons for striving to come up with a better system than what we're doing know in the industrialized Western countries.
Namaste.
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer? // Urine charge!!
Sat, March 31, 2007 - 3:26 AMHere's a personal story and some scientific data on the use of urine as a plant fertilizer. Several pictures are also there to document the results.
www.solviva.com/seeking_the_path.htm
It is a free chapter of the book "Solviva." Several other free chapters are also accessible from that website. -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer? // Urine charge!!
Sun, April 1, 2007 - 12:15 AMYay for this great thing. I put my used organic cotton tampons in the compost. :)
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, April 1, 2007 - 11:57 AMI just joined this tribe and must say this a wonderful conversation.
For the last 5 years I have been using sea sponge for my blood. And it is fantastic. I use my own blood in ritual ( letting go, cleansing) but honestly never got around using it in the garden.
I have a friend who urinates on his roses and they are the best roses around :-)
This spring I will start to use the blood in the herb garden. Thanks for the reminder. -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Thu, April 24, 2008 - 7:17 PMJust bringing this topic alive again! :)
I use my blood on my garden, it is wonderful stuff. -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, May 9, 2008 - 3:12 AMI am glad that you did. This is all new information to me as I am newer to Tribe and would have missed it... I don't really go back through old topics because it's time consuming. Thank you for the resurrection, it has made me think quite a bit. :)
-
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, July 16, 2010 - 8:23 AMWell, here we are another 2 years later, and as one poster said, it IS like a living book!
I have used urine on my garden, and my plants are the BIGGEST I have ever had! I did a lot of research before doing this, to discover that urine is sterile when it comes out - just be sure to use it fairly soon, as it will go back quickly (the ammonia smell will get you usually by the end of the day!)
As for Menstrual blood, I have used it on house plants for some years (I own a Diva cup, very similar to the keeper mentioned, and love it...I also soak cloth pads in water. I tuck them into a kool-aid pitcher that I set aside specifically for this purpose (I painted it with some moon and stars and keep it in the closet in the bathroom) with some water and let them soak. I use the blood the next day. If you let it wait too long, it also goes bad and I wouldn't even recommend it on house plants at that point. I am not sure about using this blood in my vegie garden, as I have not done enough research to discover how sterile it is or what chances of blood-borne illness could be caused from it.
I agree that there is a combination of science fears coupled with fears of women's power out there. It's nice to see the people who have responded to this thread have not just come to say "Eww, that's repulsive, so go get a life you wierdo", but instead are being very thoughtful about their responses. This has been a great thread to read! I personally feel that women's creative energy is contained within their menstrual blood, and therefore I like the idea of giving it back to the earth.
I have also read about the issues of sewage problems, drinking water issues, etc. I believe that in areas where this is the biggest problem, it is due to the feces and not the urine. I know of some folks who compost their feces to make humanure, and I suspect it is a great fertilizer for the earth. It seems to me that as a race, we humans have somewhat lost our connection to the earth. We have been mistreating her for so long, and I know many of us are well-intentioned and want to start to reverse that damage and treat her better.
We can make small changes at a time, which I believe will ultimately add up. So, fertilize the items you feel safe to work with, and as you do so, pour your intentions into the act. Make it a deliberate offering to Mother Earth, and send your love with it into the earth. Let her know we're all doing our best, one change at a time :)
Blessings from Maine :) -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, July 18, 2010 - 2:01 PMI loved juicy's comment on her friend winning at the state fair for the giant zucchini. I'm guessing she didn't tell them about her secret fertilizer. :-D
re: the smell- in my experinece, if you soak pads or whatever you use in water and use the liquid promptly, there is no bad smell, though it has it's scent. covering the container restricts the airflow, and so gets much smellier much faster, in my experience. if it's a hot season or climate, the decomposting action gets accelerated, so you need to use the liquid even faster. if the smell gets bad, i don't use it in potted plants, since there isn't as much beneficial microbial action or dilution as there is outside in the soil. a nastly smell means the less helpful anaerobic bacteria has taken over because the balance is off.
re: how much to use/limits on use/how diluted: i think about how often in nature plants get mammal blood poured directly on them. not so often, right? and it would get very diluted down through the soil structure. so vary the plants you feed, dilute generously with water, and spread out the bounty. with any kind of fertilizer, gentle and occasional use is usually best. plants have seasons of dormancy, and need periods of less nutrition in order to do that.
re: hygiene: i don't worry about this because i don't put in on food crops and there's a long, long tradition of women doing this for generations before us. common respect tells me to not use the liquid on plant foods or anything used for people who aren't in the know or who don't like this idea. -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, September 19, 2010 - 1:26 PMHIV? E coli? lol this is ridiculous! Noone should ever freely broadcast urine,fecees,semen or blood of anykind muchless menstral over the garden .. We compost people .....Hello? the compost process cooks your diarhea and dueche rags with an intense heat that destroys all pathogens and renders them into inert organic goodness suitable for your strawberry patch.... what do you think the Mayans were doing 1000s of years ago? Tera prata is humanure and this stuff is legendary! i would gladly except any and all donations of menstral blood as I have no way of making my own.. and if u think compost activators and such products have a place in the garden then you are truley in the wrong place ,because urine,fresh from our bodys is mother natures own compost activator and to my knowledge has no equal... please if ever s Tx feel free to shit in my compost pile but not in my garden.. love your mother
-
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Fri, November 19, 2010 - 9:58 AMIt has been some time since this conversation started and I am wondering how people's experiments have turned out. I have been using my menstrual pad soaking water as fertilizer for a palm tree and an ornamental fig tree, both houseplants, and they have been doing really well. I am interested in using it as a fertilizer for hydroponic growing of lettuce, kale and beans. Any suggestions?
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Tue, April 19, 2011 - 1:21 PMI have used menstrual blood to water my house plants, and what is left over of the soulution goes out onto the lawn. It has not attracted any ants, freaky bugs or wild animals. I do have some really healthy plants and a great lawn though :-) My flower garden is flourising. BTW not even my cat seems to notice the smell. I haven't done a side by side comparaison though. Good idea LoL -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, April 24, 2011 - 7:34 PMurine is sterile -
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, April 24, 2011 - 7:37 PMurine can even be utilized to heal
the worst of disease
-
-
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sat, May 7, 2011 - 3:16 PMI don't want to sound like I'm accusing anybody of anything. My 2 main concerns would be (a) pathogens and (b) any type of disease. If I were gettilng blood from a person well enough to know they are disease free, fine. If I met the person a few days ago neither that person and I know each other that well. In other words that person doesn't know me well enough to be assured that I'm disease free.
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Mon, August 22, 2011 - 8:50 AMThis is a great thread. I was actually looking up if Menstrual Blood was ever used for tests and if not why...and I tripped across this topic. What got me searching in the first place is my introduction to the wonderful invention of the "Diva Cup" www.divacup.com/ . I found it a wonderful alternative to tampons (though pads are still required) and you can not only see how much blood that passes through ones system but it actually tells you on the side of the cup. So after a few months (very easy to use and cuts costs too) my curiousity was peaked about the menses on many levels. I like the positive idea of giving it back to the earth instead of disposing it in the toilet. This way it transforms from "waste" into "fertilzation" of one form or another. I am only promoting the diva cup because I am happy with it. I had alot of issues with cramping etc...and this alternative is a much better choice for myself. The other benifit of the divia cup is if you were to mix it with a water soultion etc...there is no trying to retrieve it from pads or tampons...its all contained. Glad I tripped across this thread...going to give back to mother earth. :) Thanks for the inspiration.
-
Re: menstrual blood as fertilizer?
Sun, May 13, 2012 - 8:34 PMUsing menstrual blood as fertilizer is a very ancient practice we have forgotten... Although some of us are intuitive enough to ask the question :) it provides nitrogen and corrects iron deficiency in plants. The blood is decomposed by microorganisms before being taken in by the plant so i would not worry about what some people have replied about blood viruses etc. Using it in this way makes us known to the plants. There is an other very ancient practice which uses body fluids such as saliva in the sprouting of the seeds. This gives the seed knowledge about the condition of our bodies and the plant will produce fruit that will balance any inbalances in our body. This process is described in a book called Anastasia RInging Cedars. I assume using our blood on more mature plants will do the same. Blood may be too strong on seedlings and their tiny roots because of the ammonia produced in the composting process of blood. As for people worrying so much about body fluids going into the water table and ending up in their well because we use it on our plants, i'd say: they shoud worry more about the dogs peeing tons all over the place and not a few drops of blood that barely get to where we need them to go.
in my opinion, the most important factor in using it as fertilizer is providing the plants, especially food plants with our energetic signature. It is also a nice practice to give back to Mother Earth and honouring the Divine feminine.
